
The Yankees have announced that Andy Pettitte has decided to retire, and a press conference tomorrow morning will officially close the book on the left hander’s illustrious career.
In his last season, Pettitte arguably was having the best year of his career, going 11-2 with a 2.70 ERA in the first half. His performance earned him a spot on the AL All-Star team, and it looked like Pettitte could actually win 20-22 games. It wasn’t out of the question at the time. But unfortunately, (maybe the reason he did ultimately decide to hang ‘em up), Pettitte suffered a groin injury in late July that sidelined him all the way up to mid-September. His final 2010 stats – 11-3, 3.28 ERA, 101 strikeouts. Who knows? Maybe if he stays healthy and wins around 19 games, he returns in 2011. But of course, that didn’t happen. And Andy Pettitte is now a former Yankee.
Andy Pettitte finishes his career with a record of 240-138 with an ERA of 3.88. His 203 wins with the Yankees (1995-2003, ’07-10) is good for third-most in Yankee history. Andy also holds the record for most-postseason wins all-time. By anyone. His 19, concluding with an ALDS Game 2 win this past fall, is certainly a statistic that can not be overlooked. Regular season, he was amazing. Postseason, he was even better.
I, being too young to remember the Yankees’ late-90′s dynasty, never got to really see Pettitte in his prime. Of course when I was old enough to start liking baseball, Pettitte was in Houston. But when he returned in 2007, I started learning about him. Watching Yankee Classics, looking up stats, etc. I found out he was a pretty kick-ass pitcher. And I hoped maybe I could see him pitch in the World Series one day. And of course, that day came last year.
I saw him give it his all in 5 2/3 innings of 3-run ball in Game 6 of the 2009 World Series. On three-days rest, the then 37-year old proved everyone wrong and was once again the winning pitcher in the clinching game of a series (he won Game 3 of ALDS, and Game 6 of ALCS). I finally was able to say I saw Andy Pettitte pitch a great game in the World Series. And I had never liked him more at that point.
Since doing my research and just overall watching him the past few years, Pettitte evolved into arguably my favorite Yankee of all-time. Just the way he was so clutch when the Yanks needed him the most, the way he handled the media, he was just a true great baseball player. Of course this applies to Derek Jeter as well, but there’s just something about Pettitte that I’ve always liked. I don’t know exactly what that is though, oddly enough.
Now of course with every retirement comes the question everyone asks – is this player worthy of the Hall of Fame? And Andy Pettitte, should be, a first ballot HOF’er. No doubt. I mean, he’s the most successful postseason pitcher of all time! 19 wins!!! The stats prove it. I know, the HGH story will probably come back to bite him, but apparently it was only for a short period of time, to help him recover from an injury in 2002. That’s no excuse, but still. He has 240 regular season wins, and yes, maybe staying for a couple more years and getting up to 270 maybe might have give him an even better shot. But, what are you gonna do. I think his resume is definitely worthy of a call to Cooperstown. And I think, he will eventually get there.
Oh, god. Here it comes. The time to make my final thoughts on Andy Pettitte. I was dreading this day, but it has come. And I think, Andy Pettitte is just a prime example of success. A five-time World Series champion, the most postseason wins, consistent all the time; he was the complete package. It will be tough not seeing #46 on the mound, but I’m sure in a little while, you’ll see that number again, in Monument Park. And that face, on a plaque, hanging, in Cooperstown, New York.
Thank you Mr. Pettitte for bringing great success to the New York Yankees organization. I, personally, will miss you a lot.